UN: press should not be ‘intimidated into silence’ over state secrets

Representatives criticise UK government following detention of David Miranda, and call for public debate over NSA surveillance

Written by Josh Halliday and Ewen MacAskill, The Guardian, http://www.theguardian.com/media/2013/sep/04/un-press-intimidation-state-secrets

Glenn Greenwald David Miranda

David Miranda (right) the partner of Guardian journalist Glenn Greewald (left) was detained by the UK government under shedule 7 of the Terrorism Act. Photograph: Ricardo Moraes/Reuters

Two senior UN representatives have warned the British government that the protection of state secrets must not be used as an excuse to “intimidate the press into silence” following the detention of David Miranda under the Terrorism Act.

Frank La Rue, the UN special rapporteur on freedom of expression, issued the caution as he called for a public debate on the mass surveillance revelations exposed by the National Security Agency whistleblower Edward Snowden.

“The protection of national security secrets must never be used as an excuse to intimidate the press into silence and backing off from its crucial work in the clarification of human rights violations,” said La Rue. “The press plays a central role in the clarification of human rights abuses.”

La Rue and Ben Emmerson, the UN special rapporteur on human rights and counter-terrorism, have written to David Cameron’s government requesting further information on the legality of Miranda’s detention at Heathrow airport on 18 August.

Documents and electronic devices carried by Miranda, the partner of the Guardian journalist Glenn Greenwald, were seized by the Metropolitan police when he was held for questioning for nine hours under schedule 7of the Terrorism Act.

La Rue said: “It is clear that the revelations on the extensive mass surveillance initiatives implemented by some governments needs to be widely debated.

“The intimidation of journalists and newspapers questioning alleged abuses by intelligence bodies is certainly not a contribution to the open debate that needs to take place. Under no circumstances, journalists, members of the media, or civil society organisations who have access to classified information on an alleged violation of human rights should be subjected to intimidation and subsequent punishment.”

Emmerson, a London-based independent expert for the UN, said theNSA revelations had proved the need for a debate on “the extent to which the public in both [the UK and US] is prepared to tolerate official access to metadata”.

He added: “The powers used in this case are currently under challenge in the European court of human rights. I urge the British authorities to review their operations to ensure that they comply fully with the UK’s obligations under the European convention on human rights regarding the right to liberty and security, and the right to respect for private and family life.”

The UN experts’ comments came as a senior Brazilian official said that Dilma Rouseff, the country’s president could cancel a planned White House visit and downgrade commercial ties after it was reported that the NSA had spied on her private communications. Rousseff is due to make a formal state visit to Washington next month to meet Barack Obamaand discuss a possible $4bn fighter plane deal, cooperation on oil and biofuels technology, as well as other commercial agreements.

On Wednesday, Obama raised for the first time the prospect of new legislation to limit the powers of the NSA. Answering a question at a joint press conference with the Swedish prime minister on his way to the G20 summit in St Petersburg, Obama said there were “legitimate questions” about the NSA. He saidthat existing laws may not be sufficient to deal with advances in technology that have allowed it to gather much more data than before.

Until now, Obama has only proposed limited changes and is awaiting recommendations from a review body he set up.

Defending the NSA, he said the US, like other countries round the world, had an intelligence operation aimed at improving the country’s understanding of what is happening globally. Since 9/11, he added, a lot of energy had been focused on counter-terrorism.

“There have been times where the procedures, because these are human endeavours, have not worked the way they should and we had to tighten them up,” Obama said in Stockholm. “And I think there are legitimate questions that have been raised about the fact that as technology advances and capabilities grow, it may be that the laws that are currently in place are not sufficient to guard against the dangers of us being able to track so much.”

In the high court last month, Britain’s deputy national security adviser, Oliver Robbins, said the government urgently needed to identify the material seized from Miranda to assess the risk to “sensitive intelligence sources and methods and the threat to intelligence agency staff” if the data fell into the hands of “hostile actors”.

However, the Guardian editor-in-chief, Alan Rusbridger, suggested the government had moved with little urgency since early June and that its rhetoric was an attempt to exploit the “dismaying blurring of terror and journalism”.

 

• To contact the MediaGuardian news desk email media@guardian.co.uk or phone 020 3353 3857. For all other inquiries please call the main Guardian switchboard on 020 3353 2000. If you are writing a comment for publication, please mark clearly “for publication”.

• To get the latest media news to your desktop or mobile, follow MediaGuardian on Twitter and Facebook

You need to be a member of Ashtar Command - Spiritual Community to add comments!

Join Ashtar Command - Spiritual Community

Email me when people reply –

Topics by Tags

Monthly Archives

Latest Activity

Justin89636 left a comment on Comment Wall
"Anybody else getting the white screen thing when coming on to here or is it just me?"
2 hours ago
AlternateEarth posted a blog post
Anthropic's Warning: Could AI Become a Threat to Humanity?Some of the people developing the world's most advanced artificial intelligence systems are warning that AI could eventually become an existential threat to humanity.Researchers associated…
16 hours ago
AlternateEarth commented on AlternateEarth's blog post Blessed Virgin Mary ‘appears’ to New Jersey child with brain tumor: report
"Thanks Justin I've self healing experiences though I believe I had help from light workers"
17 hours ago
Justin89636 commented on AlternateEarth's blog post Blessed Virgin Mary ‘appears’ to New Jersey child with brain tumor: report
"Georges Cordoba as seen here also has a great story about how he healed himself. It only mentions his diet in the title of the video, but it goes way beyond that. https://youtu.be/JReHdxHJhu0?si=8saEfr9NXpmB0qer"
20 hours ago
Justin89636 commented on AlternateEarth's blog post Blessed Virgin Mary ‘appears’ to New Jersey child with brain tumor: report
"I would imagine combining prayer with certain diets and fasting together would definitely work for many. Other ways to of course like what Gregg Braden shows."
20 hours ago
Love & Joy posted a discussion
  This Is A Time For Quantum Healing By Patricia Cota-Robles   The Company of Heaven is revealing that with the awesome influxes of Light we experienced during the Opening of the Lion’s Gate and the August 2026 Eclipse Series, Humanity en masse is…
20 hours ago
rev.joshua skirvin posted a blog post
Posted on 09/09/2026 by EraOfLight — 1 Comment ↓ I am Michael and I serve God. I love you very much. I am very old and I will speak about something that is lost in this modern time, and it was common knowledge a long time ago.Heart and mind are…
20 hours ago
AlternateEarth commented on AlternateEarth's blog post Blessed Virgin Mary ‘appears’ to New Jersey child with brain tumor: report
"Here's a Brit who should be Sainted for healing-all documented;
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xB8oTgPlalo"
20 hours ago
More…